Trusted Poker Guide Since 2004
About UsContactResponsible Gambling
PokerSites.orgPlay Now โ†’
๐Ÿ† Best Poker Sites๐Ÿ’ฐ Best Bonuses๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ US Poker๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡ฆ CA Poker๐Ÿ“Š Traffic Rankings๐Ÿ“ฑ Mobile Poker๐ŸŽฐ Online Casinoโšฝ Sportsbook
News

Senators Press CFTC on Geofencing Order

By jason-murphyยทNovember 22, 2026ยท6 min read

Nine Democratic U.S. senators have told the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to reverse its prediction market geofencing order, escalating the fight over whether platforms such as Kalshi can offer sports event contracts in states that consider them illegal sports betting. The letter, dated November 16 and first reported by The Wall Street Journal, also demands that the agency preserve records and communications going back to January 2025, and asks for a written response by November 23.

The letter is addressed to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig and was led by Sen. Adam Schiff of California. As Card Player reported, the senators warned that the CFTC's "unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders" and must be reversed.

Who Signed the Letter

The nine signatories all represent states with commercial or tribal gaming industries, which helps explain why this issue has become so politically charged:

  • Adam Schiff (California)
  • Alex Padilla (California)
  • Amy Klobuchar (Minnesota), ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC
  • Catherine Cortez Masto (Nevada)
  • Jacky Rosen (Nevada)
  • Maria Cantwell (Washington)
  • Patty Murray (Washington)
  • Elissa Slotkin (Michigan)
  • Gary Peters (Michigan)

Nevada, Michigan, Washington and California are all states where courts or regulators have pushed back against sports event contracts. Card Player also noted that the November midterms gave Democrats majorities in both chambers of Congress, which gives the letter more weight than a similar request might have carried a year ago.

What the CFTC's Geofencing Order Says

On November 5, the CFTC issued an interpretation of its impartial-access rule for designated contract markets, Regulation 38.151(b). According to Gambling.com, the interpretation says exchanges must end domestic geographic restrictions that breach the rule within 30 days, or explain to the Division of Market Oversight why compliance is not feasible. Intermediaries that route customers to exchanges are also told not to block users.

Selig argued that derivatives markets must operate on a "uniform national basis." In practice, that means Kalshi and similar platforms would be expected to offer their sports contracts in every state, including states that have won court orders treating those contracts as unlicensed sports betting.

The timing drew immediate criticism. The order came hours after a federal court in the Northern District of California ruled in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi that Kalshi must geofence the tribe's land. Schiff has said the CFTC effectively wants contracts offered across all 50 states and on tribal lands, regardless of what courts have decided.

The Senators' Demands

The letter makes two main requests.

1. Withdraw or freeze the order. The senators' primary ask is that the CFTC withdraw the November 5 interpretation, or at least suspend it until the litigation is resolved. As a fallback, they want the agency to confirm that three types of geographic restrictions do not violate the rule: limits required by a court order, limits adopted to comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or tribal-state compacts, and limits that platforms adopt voluntarily.

2. Preserve records. The senators asked the CFTC to preserve all records and communications from January 1, 2025 onward, including personal email, messaging apps and voicemail, and to suspend any auto-delete settings. They also questioned whether the agency has been coordinating with the platforms that are litigating against the states.

The Legal Battlefield

The letter lands in the middle of a sprawling legal fight. The senators point out that numerous courts have held that sports event contracts are effectively indistinguishable from sports bets under state and tribal law. Court orders in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and on two California tribes' lands, require platforms to stop offering certain contracts. The Sixth and Ninth Circuits have ruled that states can apply their gaming laws to prediction markets, and the Ninth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in a Nevada case.

Not every court agrees. New Jersey's case went Kalshi's way, and New Jersey has asked the US Supreme Court to settle the question. So far the Court has declined to take it up, according to Card Player.

Meanwhile, the CFTC has gone on the offensive. It and the Department of Justice sued Louisiana after a state judge ordered more than 30 prediction market firms to cease operations, making Louisiana the 12th state the CFTC has sued, per Card Player. Selig called Louisiana's actions "naked lawfare." Deadspin also reported that Utah filed felony charges against Kalshi's co-founders, after which the CFTC sued Utah. We covered the Louisiana and Arkansas fight in our report on the CFTC lawsuits against Arkansas and Louisiana, and the original order in our story on the CFTC's 30-day geofencing order.

Why This Matters for Sports Bettors and Poker Players

On the surface, prediction markets and poker are separate worlds. In reality, they are tightly connected. The same state regulators who license online poker and sports betting are the ones fighting Kalshi, and the same tax bases are at stake. Tribal gaming operators, which run many of the country's card rooms, have been among the most aggressive litigants.

If the CFTC's order stands, it would hand the federal government sweeping control over a form of sports wagering, weakening the state-by-state model that governs everything from legal sportsbooks to online poker. If the senators win, states keep the power to decide what counts as gambling within their borders. That outcome would also strengthen states' hands when they consider new online poker legislation.

For bettors, the practical message is uncertainty. A prediction market contract that is available in your state today could be geofenced tomorrow, and rules can change with a single court ruling. Bettors who want a stable product have options at established offshore books. Our reviews of the BetOnline sportsbook and SportsBetting.ag, along with our sportsbooks guide, explain how those sites work and how to fund them with crypto.

What Comes Next

The senators asked for a written response by November 23. Selig has said the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction over prediction markets and has vowed to take the fight to the Supreme Court if necessary. With Democrats now holding majorities in both chambers, the agency may face oversight hearings and appropriations pressure in the new Congress.

The 30-day compliance window in the November 5 order runs into early December, so the next few weeks will show whether platforms begin removing geofences, whether courts block the order, or whether the CFTC softens its position. Either way, the conflict between federal derivatives law and state gaming law is now one of the most important regulatory stories in US gambling.

Tags:prediction marketsCFTCKalshisports bettinggambling regulation

Related Articles

18+ only. Gambling can be addictive โ€” please play responsibly. PokerSites.org is an independent guide not operated by any gambling operator. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, contact NCPG (1-800-GAMBLER), BeGambleAware, or GamCare.